In recent years, training while fasted and time-restricted eating (TRE) have become hot-button topics in the health and fitness world.
The promise of better fat-burning, enhanced mitochondrial adaptations, and even improved longevity has driven countless exercisers to skip breakfast and lace up their running shoes on an empty stomach.
But how much of that hype holds up under scientific scrutiny? And more importantly, does fasted training make sense for everyone?
In a recent conversation with Dr. Andy Galpin, a leading exercise physiologist and director of the Human Performance Center at Parker University, the science got a serious reality check — and the truth may surprise you.
Key Takeaway: Fasted training can have subtle benefits, but it’s far from essential
Yes, training while fasted can enhance some adaptations related to fat oxidation and mitochondrial efficiency — particularly during moderate, sub-60-minute aerobic efforts like Zone 2 running.
But for most people, the physiological gains are relatively minor compared to the personal preference and how you feel during training.
“If you feel better training fasted, great. But if you don’t? There’s no magic you’re missing out on,” said Galpin.
He emphasized that preference and performance outweigh the small boost in fat metabolism you might see from fasted cardio. If you dread your morning workout without food, there’s no need to force it.
Training Goals Matter: Endurance vs. Strength
Not all training benefits equally from a fasted approach.
- Endurance workouts under 60 minutes (especially Zone 2) may benefit slightly from fasted conditions due to increases in mitochondrial enzymes and fat oxidation.
- Strength training, however, is a different story. Most people perform better with at least some carbohydrate intake beforehand — even something as simple as a banana or small yogurt.
Fasted lifting, especially when heavy or intense, may reduce performance and compromise training volume over time.
Metabolic Flexibility Is Not Just About Burning Fat
The term metabolic flexibility gets tossed around often, usually framed as “being fat-adapted.” But according to Galpin, that’s a misunderstanding.
“Metabolic flexibility means being able to use both carbs and fats effectively — not just maximizing fat burning,” he explained.
He argued that someone should be able to go 24 hours without food and still maintain performance — not because they’re fat-adapted, but because their metabolism is resilient. That’s the real goal: adaptability, not specialization.
Time-Restricted Eating and Muscle Gain: Surprising Results
Galpin shared details of a just-published study from his lab exploring the effects of an 8-hour feeding window (16:8 TRE) on muscle growth. The twist? Participants trained in the morning while fasted and delayed eating until later in the day.
Despite concerns, the results were surprisingly neutral.
- Both groups (TRE and traditional eating) gained muscle and strength when total protein and calories were matched.
- However, TRE participants reported higher fatigue, and some saw reduced training volume over time, especially in leg exercises.
So while TRE didn’t sabotage muscle gains, it introduced adherence challenges — especially in those consuming large amounts of protein and carbs in a compressed window.
Total Daily Nutrition > Pre-Workout Meal
For people focused on body recomposition — fat loss and muscle gain — nutrient timing (like eating right before or after a workout) matters less than total daily intake.
What does matter?
- Sufficient protein intake: Around 1.6–2.2 g/kg/day
- Caloric balance: Whether in deficit or surplus
- Consistency over time
However, Galpin noted that for those training multiple times per day, or doing high-volume endurance work, carbohydrate timing does become more important — especially post-exercise to replenish glycogen.
Fats Still Matter — But Aren’t Priority #1
Fat tends to be the forgotten macronutrient. While protein and carbs dominate sports nutrition talk, fat has crucial roles:
- Hormone production
- Cell membrane integrity
- Fat-soluble vitamin absorption
But for most exercisers, as long as fat intake isn’t too low (below ~10% of total calories), performance likely won’t suffer. In fact, Galpin says many clients do just fine — even with heavy training loads — on moderate to low carbs and higher fat, if they prefer it and meet calorie needs.
“We’ve had high-volume runners perform just fine at 150 grams of carbs a day,” he said.
What About Endurance Athletes and Carb Timing?
Fasted cardio might be tolerable for short, low-to-moderate intensity sessions, but for longer or high-intensity efforts, carbohydrate intake becomes critical.
- 3–4 hours pre-exercise: 50–100g of complex carbs (e.g., oats, rice)
- 30 minutes before: Some may benefit from simple carbs, but be cautious of glucose crashes
- During exercise: For long events, aim for 60–100g of carbs per hour
Galpin emphasized the importance of training your gut for races, not just your muscles. GI issues on race day often stem from unfamiliar fueling strategies.
Is Protein Timing Overhyped?
While protein intake is essential for muscle growth and recovery, the concept of the “anabolic window” may be overblown.
- Total daily protein is far more important than exact timing.
- That said, for those struggling to hit their targets, pre-bed protein (like 30–40g of casein or cottage cheese) may help — especially in older adults or during heavy training phases.
Whole Food Beats Powder (Almost) Every Time
A standout takeaway from Galpin’s comments was the prioritization of whole foods over supplements — even for protein.
“You don’t have to have protein powder ever,” he stated. “Whole food is always the answer.”
He referenced a study comparing whole eggs to egg whites, where whole eggs led to slightly greater muscle growth, despite being matched for protein and calories — suggesting additional nutrients in the yolk may matter.
Bottom Line: Context Is King
There’s no one-size-fits-all approach to fueling workouts. Instead of rigid rules, Galpin recommends:
- Assessing how you feel during training
- Identifying your performance and body goals
- Evaluating your total calorie and protein intake
- Choosing what you can sustain long-term
In the end, the best approach isn’t the one that looks best on paper — it’s the one that fits your physiology, preferences, and lifestyle.
发表回复